The New Rick Livermore Site

Friday, February 9, 2024

Four Views on Heaven

To regularly receive deals on Zondervan Academic books, subscribe here.

Four Views on Heaven

John S. Feinberg, J. Richard Middleton, Michael Allen, Peter Kreeft, Michael E. Wittmer

Most people have not thought too hard about heaven. They tend to think of it like the final line of a children's story, "And they all lived happily ever after." They assume that those who have died are now in heaven doing whatever they did on earth, only better. If someone enjoyed golf, he is smashing long drives down the middle of celestial fairways. If someone loved to paint, she is setting up her easel in front of a glorious vista. And if their friend played the banjo, he is now jamming in heaven's band. Which is unbelievable. There are banjoes in heaven?!

Seriously, even Christians have not thought too deeply about what happens when we die. We tend to run all of God's promised future together, assuming that we get everything he has promised all at once. Funeral sermons often say that our loved one is right now playing baseball, baking pies, or writing poetry that is out of this world. We seldom stop and ask, Really? How is she doing these things? We can see her body in the casket, awaiting its resurrection. Someday she may do all this, but now?

This is a good time to note that when it comes to eschatology, the Christian Scriptures teach the three Rs: the Return of Christ, the Resurrection of the body, and the Restoration of all things. Praise God that our loved ones who died in Christ are now "with the Lord" (2 Cor 5:8), but they apparently have not yet received all that God has promised them.1 They are still waiting for their resurrection bodies that they will receive when Jesus returns to this earth (1 Thess 4:16). Like a wise parent who only allows her children to open their stockings on Christmas Eve, so our Father does not give us every gift we have coming the moment we die. He gives us the best gift we have ever received, for we pass immediately from this life into the arms of our Savior. But God saves even more presents for the Christmas morning of Christ's return and our resurrection. Only then will our redemption be complete; only then will we be restored in every possible way.

At the end of the day, when all is said and done, where will Christians live forever?

Here is the point: many Christians make an eschatological mess by blurring together the various stages of the afterlife. Theologians typically avoid such confusion by distinguishing God's promised future for individual believers into the "intermediate state" and "the final state." The Bible says little about the intermediate state except that we are with the Lord (Luke 23:43; 2 Cor 5:6–8; Phil 1:21–23; 1 Thess 4:14). And this is enough. Unlike "heavenly tourism" books that celebrate the journeys of people who went to heaven and returned without laying eyes on Jesus, the Bible indicates that what makes heaven "heavenly" is the presence of Jesus. Yet the intermediate state is not the focus of Scripture. Its eye is on the end, when Jesus returns to resurrect and judge all people and restore all things (Acts 3:21; Col 1:20; Rev 20–22).

Four Views on Heaven is about the intermediate state, what happens when Christians die. It is about our final state, what happens after that. At the end of the day, when all is said and done, where will Christians live forever? What will that place be like, and what will we do there?

Four views on Heaven explores these views:

Traditional Heaven - our destiny is to leave earth and live forever in heaven where we will rest, worship, and serve God (John S. Feinberg)

Restored Earth - emphasizes that the saved will live forever with Jesus on this restored planet, enjoying ordinary human activities in our redeemed state. (J. Richard Middleton)

Heavenly Earth - a balanced view that seeks to highlight both the strengths and weaknesses of the heavenly and earthly views (Michael Allen).

Roman Catholic Beatific Vision - stresses the intellectual component of salvation, though it encompasses the whole of human experience of joy, happiness coming from seeing God finally face-to-face (Peter Kreeft).

Encounter God’s Heart…Lessons Learned

Encounter God's Heart…

Lessons Learned

Life is full of many lessons that we all must learn. Some learn the hard way, while others allow the wisdom of the instruction and experience of others to inform their practices. We see this in history, family systems, and the people around us. We must not be so full of pride that we won't allow the lived experience of others to teach us what not to do.

This is not to say that any of us can avoid failure. It is a part of life. But we can learn from the wisdom of those who have gone before us. We do not have to make the same mistakes they did, and we can start from a place of humble understanding. We can see this play out in the sciences. We have a basis of working knowledge, theories, and discoveries. We build upon what has already been discovered so we can go further. Let's do this with our spiritual lives as well.

Father, you know my needs, wants, and dreams. As I lay them before you today and focus on you, I know you'll take care of every one. I'm going to start focusing more on the things I have to be thankful for than the problems that have weighed heavily on my mind. I want nothing to consume my heart more than my desire for you. The true riches of your kingdom are found in life with you.

From Wisdom from Above written by Brian Simmons

Proverbs 21:11

The Passion Translation

Senseless people learn their lessons the hard way, but the wise are teachable.

LATEST BLOG

Blog image: woman sitting on a rock reading the Bible

Trusting God with Every Breath by Amy Mecham

Once upon a time, there lived a little girl who had a big heart and lots of love to give. She lived with her sweet parents, younger brother, and 2 kitties. Her world was her room, which was filled with toys, dolls, and books. She wanted for nothing. She had everything...

Read More

SPOTLIGHT

The Chosen Novels 1-3: Boxed Set by Jerry B. Jenkins

From time to time something special comes along that we just can't help but share. The Chosen is one such thing!

Based on the acclaimed video series The Chosen, the life of Jesus gets a fresh, new telling in this novel series from New York Times bestselling author Jerry B. Jenkins. This special boxed set contains the first three novels in the series.